Log in:
Username
Password
Keep me logged in (help)

Forgot username or password?

Create new login

You can change the width of the story text shown below:
Use how much percent of the screen width?

[ default ] [ 10% ] [ 20% ] [ 30% ] [ 40% ] [ 50% ] [ 60% ] [ 70% ] [ 80% ] [ 90% ] [ 100% ]

Options: Plain text or PDF (fanclub only!) version  |  Mark story  |  Mark author

Don't forget to vote for this story, in the yellow voting box below the story!

After that first football weekend and hooking up with both Mary Beth and Jennifer I discovered that they both wanted more...as in relationship more. Jennifer wanted me back! She had broken up with me THREE times, once to be free to do who or whatever she wanted for spring break, once because she believed I had cheated on her (I hadn't) because of that evil Jackie's lies, and the last time over a silly argument (no, that was just an excuse) maybe because she was tired of me. I don't know. I was suspicious Jennifer wanted me back just because another girl she knew very well wanted me. Mary Beth had let me know that she really did want to try and develop something with me. Both girls were deeply imbedded in my social clique with strong ties to my friends. Brittany believed that Jennifer broke up with to to experiment and play around but all along wanted to get me back when she was good and ready. Jennifer had always had a hold on me and could have probably done that but all of the sudden somebody came along, Mary Beth, who might could steal me away from Jennifer permanently.

For a few weeks I had been able to hold them off in a status quo situation with me making no commitments to either but reaping the benefits because they were both fucking the hell out of me. But the friction was increasing and they were both putting pressure on me. I was feeling a lot of stress over it. They both knew I was having sex with the other and I was trying to be careful not to flaunt it in front of the either one. And there was no doubt that both girls were competing because every sexual encounter it seemed like they tried to ...

This story is part of the EroticStories.com FanClub archive. Therefore, you can only see the first few lines. If you want to see the rest, you can join the FanClub. All stories that have the small 'a' (this icon: ) behind the title are part of this archive and only available to members of the EroticStories FanClub. Stories that were posted in the last 60 days are NOT part of the fanclub, so you can fully read those. The easiest way to get to those stories is to check the new stories list or the top stories list.

stories in "one-on-one"   |   all stories by "FinsUp"