Renegotiating (fm:one-on-one, 8959 words) [6/6] show all parts | |||
| Author: Storey Lover | |||
| Added: Apr 19 2026 | Views / Reads: 69 / 57 [83%] | Part vote: 9.80 (1 vote) | |
| Sadie renegotiates her commitment to Santiago. Matteo's steamy fling with Aubrey and sorority threesome can't quell his inner void. Steamy & soul-searching. | |||
You can change the width of the story text shown below:
Use how much percent of the screen width?
| [ default ] [ 10% ] [ 20% ] [ 30% ] [ 40% ] [ 50% ] [ 60% ] [ 70% ] [ 80% ] [ 90% ] [ 100% ] |
Options: Plain text or PDF (fanclub only!) version | Mark story | Mark author
Don't forget to vote for this story, in the yellow voting box below the story!
Click here to read the first 75 lines of the story
circling the hardening peaks of her nipples until they poked insistently against the white material. Jolts of electricity shot straight to her core with every touch.Matteo kissed lower, his breath warm against her sternum as he nuzzled the fabric over her breasts, teeth grazing the poking skin through the dress in teasing little bites that made her gasp. He moved down her body with deliberate slowness, the textured crop of his hair brushing like velvet over her stomach. When he reached the toned length of her inner thighs, Aubrey’s breathing turned rapid and erratic, her chest rising and falling in shallow waves.
He kissed upward along the sensitive skin, each press of his lips leaving a trail of heat. His fingers hooked the hem of her dress, slowly pushing it higher and higher until the fabric bunched at her hips. Aubrey sat up just enough to tug the dress off over her head in one fluid motion, revealing high-cut white bikini panties that barely contained the growing dampness between her legs. Matteo settled deep between her thighs, his face inches from the thin barrier of fabric. Her fingers instinctively tangled in his short hair, pulling him closer as a pulse of raw heat surged through her entire body.
His tongue extended, tracing slow, swirling circles over the fabric right against her clit. The wet friction of cotton and heat made her arch her back sharply, then bow it downward with a low, throaty moan that vibrated through her chest. Both hands held his head in place, her nails grazing his scalp as his nose pressed firmly against her pubic mound, inhaling her scent. The pressure built in delicious waves, her hips rocking subtly against his mouth.
Matteo curled his fingers under the sides of her panties and peeled them down her long legs, tossing them aside. Her smooth, bronze mound glistened under the low lamplight, slick with the evidence of her arousal. He dove back in without hesitation, his mouth and tongue giving her swollen clit and slick lips the full attention they ached for, long, flat licks followed by precise flicks and gentle suction. Aubrey’s long, slender body arched again, a primal groan tearing from her throat as the first climax crashed through her like a wave breaking on rock. Her powerful legs draped over his broad shoulders, heels digging into his back to pull him impossibly closer, holding his head exactly where she needed it as a second, deeper orgasm followed on its heels. Her eyes rolled back, head tilting, every muscle in her core clenching and releasing in uncontrollable spasms.
Juices flowed freely over his tongue and lips as he intensified his efforts, lapping and sucking with relentless skill. A third climax ripped through her, then a fourth and fifth, each stronger, more explosive, her body shaking violently in his grip. She had lost all control, thighs trembling, fingers fisted tight in his hair as instinct kept him pinned there, chasing the relentless waves of heat that refused to stop.
Slowly, carefully, Matteo rose to his feet, strong arms hooking under her hips to lift her slightly. Her still-pulsating pussy stayed pressed to his face as he held her suspended, her back arched in a graceful bow, arms and hands bracing against the bed for balance. A sixth and seventh orgasm tore through her in quick succession, her long, strong legs shaking without mercy, toes curling as she gasped and moaned.
He lowered her gently back onto the mattress, her body limp and glowing with sweat. Matteo stood at the foot of the bed, unbuttoning his dress shirt with deliberate fingers, revealing the sculpted planes of his chest and abdomen inch by inch. Aubrey sat up on shaky elbows, eyes dark with hunger as she reached for the button and zipper of his slacks. The fabric was strained obscenely by the thick outline of his fully engorged cock. She tugged them down, revealing the massive bulge in his black boxer briefs.
On the handful of basketball players she’d been with before, she’d seen impressive size but nothing like this. Her hands slid down the ridges of his abs, tracing the sharp V that disappeared beneath the waistband. She hooked her fingers there and pulled slowly, deliberately, revealing inch after veiny, girthy inch of his eleven-inch member.
“Holy fucking shit…” Aubrey breathed in genuine awe, her voice husky as the monster finally sprang free and accidentally slapped against her cheek with a heavy, warm weight. She couldn’t help the surprised laugh that bubbled out. “You’ll put someone’s eye out one day.”
Entranced, she leaned in and enveloped the broad, leaking tip and the first thick inch into the wet heat of her mouth. Her tongue swirled lazily against the sensitive frenulum, savoring the salty-sweet burst of pre-cum that oozed generously onto her taste buds. She took another two inches, wrapping one hand around the thick base and stroking slowly while her other hand joined to add pressure. Her tongue continued its teasing dance along the underside of his shaft, tracing every pulsing vein.
Matteo’s head tipped back with a deep groan, his hips bucking each time, involuntarily pulling him deeper. She worked eight and a half inches into her throat before the tip nudged the back of it, triggering a wet gag that made her eyes water and saliva drool down his length in shiny strands. She pulled back just enough, hands pumping faster, tighter, feeling the furious heartbeat throbbing through the veins encircling his cock.
His balls swelled heavy against her fingers as she built the pressure with expert rhythm. Matteo’s breathing turned fast and erratic, moans and low groans spilling from his lips as the tension in his pelvis coiled tighter. He grabbed a fistful of her updo, pulling her an inch closer as she applied maximum suction. His balls drew up tight, and with a primal grunt, the first powerful surge of semen exploded against the back of her throat. His glutes clenched, hips thrusting forward in short, instinctive strokes that fucked her face with raw need, each push smashing against her gag reflex and sending more thick ropes splashing down. Her eyes watered, mouth overflowing with a messy mix of semen and saliva as she coughed and swallowed around him, reminding herself to breathe through her nose until the final, shuddering spurt.
He released her hair, and she pulled off, gasping, long, thick ropes of drool and cum still connecting her beautiful lips to his glistening shaft. Matteo looked down to see Aubrey gazing up at him with a satisfied, wicked smile, thick fluids dripping from her chin. He helped her stand, steadying her on shaky legs as she rasped, voice raw from the effort, “That right there is a baby maker no matter how much birth control someone takes.”
Matteo chuckled softly, walking to his nightstand and pulling out a condom. He ripped the packet open and rolled it down his still-hard length with practiced ease. Aubrey climbed onto the bed, lying back in the center with her knees bent and long legs parted in open invitation, her pussy still slick and swollen from earlier.
He accepted it eagerly, crawling between her thighs and kissing a slow, reverent path from her knees upward along the sensitive inner skin. His mouth engulfed her puffy lips, tongue sliding deep between them to lap up the fresh flood of her nectar. Aubrey grabbed two handfuls of his hair and shoved his face flush against her, driving his tongue deeper into her soaking channel. “Oh God, oh God, I’m cumming again,” she groaned, body convulsing hard as another flood of warm liquid coated his tongue and chin.
Knowing she was more than ready, Matteo slid up her body, kissing the hot, sweaty plane of her stomach, between her breasts, along her neck. One hand guided his thick tip to part her dripping folds. With one smooth, powerful stroke, he buried himself to the hilt, the broad head pressing firmly against her cervix.
Aubrey’s breath hitched sharply. “Holy fuck!” she gasped, eyes wide as she felt every inch stretching and filling her walls completely.
He pulled back until just the tip remained inside, then thrust forward again, setting a slow, deliberate rhythm that gradually built in speed. Aubrey’s breathing synced with his movements, soft moans escaping with every deep plunge. Minutes later, a cluster of orgasms rocked her violently, her body shaking and quivering uncontrollably, Kegel muscles clenching and releasing in rhythmic spasms around his thick shaft. “Ahhh, I’m cumming, I’m cumming,” she uttered breathlessly as a second and third wave crashed through her, her own lubrication flooding out around his cock with wet, obscene sounds. Matteo grunted deeply, hips snapping faster until, after fifteen powerful thrusts, his balls tightened and emptied load after heavy load into the stretched condom.
He pulled out carefully, pinching the base of the condom to keep it from spilling as he removed it. Aubrey lay there, legs splayed open, chest heaving, skin glistening with sweat. They collapsed beside each other, breathing heavily, trading small, lazy smiles and soft words.
“Damn, that was amazing,” Aubrey murmured once her breath returned, one hand resting lightly on his chest.
Matteo smirked, propping himself on an elbow. “Do you want to go again?”
She glanced down. His cock was still engorged, twitching visibly with every deep breath. Aubrey laughed softly, reaching out to grasp the thick length and stroke it slowly. “I won’t be able to walk if I do,” she said, but her hand sped up, the other joining to add pressure. She sat up, leaning down to lick and swirl her tongue around the sensitive underside of his tip. A long strand of drool dripped from her lips onto his shaft as her grip tightened and her strokes turned faster, rougher.
Matteo’s breathing grew erratic again, body tensing. She swirled her tongue around the entire head as fresh pre-cum beaded and oozed. Sensing the edge, she pulled her face back, hands working frantically. His body shuddered hard, and a huge rope of cum launched into the air, splashing across his chest in thick white streaks. Aubrey gripped him firmly, pausing the stroke for a second before delivering hard, purposeful pumps like cocking a shotgun, each one forcing another thick glob onto his abs and chest until the flow slowed to smaller spurts.
When he was finally spent, puddles of semen pooled at the base of his shaft, across his abdomen, and in the valley between his pecs. Aubrey leaned in, swirling her mouth around the tip and down the shaft, slurping the collected pool with deliberate, sensual suction while holding eye contact. Her tongue traced upward, kissing and licking gently until she reached the second puddle, repeating the slow, cat-like lapping. Finally, she moved to the largest pool between his pecs, smearing it across his skin with her tongue before licking every drop clean.
They lay together for long minutes afterward, recuperating in comfortable silence broken only by soft laughter and easy conversation. Eventually, they rinsed off together in a quick, steamy shower. Aubrey spent a few extra minutes carefully applying oil to her scalp and wrapping her obsidian curls in a silk scarf, a nightly ritual of protection she and her twin sister had practiced together since they were girls. hands still wandering lazily before Matteo drove her back to her dorm, the night air cool through the open windows.
In the passenger seat on the short drive back, Aubrey’s mind drifted ahead to her International Studies midterms and the brutal afternoon volleyball practice looming. She recognized the pull she felt toward Matteo, his six-foot-six, nearly two-hundred-pound frame, that golden-brown skin, the way he moved like he owned every space he entered, but she simply didn’t have the emotional bandwidth for anything traditional. Her fortress mentality remained intact; her scholarship and goals came first.
Matteo, the extrovert who had zero interest in a committed relationship this early in his college career, found her directness refreshing. He was open about enjoying the company and bodies of any willing woman who crossed his path, and he appreciated her confidence in return.
They pulled up outside her dorm, the engine idling softly. “So… friends with benefits?” Aubrey asked, turning to him with a small, knowing smile.
Matteo grinned, reaching over to tuck a stray ringlet hair behind her ear. “Exactly. No strings, just… this. Whenever our schedules line up.”
“Deal,” she said, leaning in for one last slow kiss before slipping out into the night.
Matteo eased the front door of the off-campus rental house shut behind him with a soft click, the sound echoing too loudly in the predawn quiet. The sky outside was still the deep indigo of very early morning, the kind that clung to Palo Alto like a secret before the first light of day bled across the hills. He stood in the entryway for a long moment, keys dangling from his fingers, the faint scent of Aubrey’s skin something warm and floral, mixed with the clean sweat of their night still clinging to his collar and the inside of his wrists. His body hummed with the afterglow: thighs pleasantly sore from the way her powerful legs had locked around his shoulders, lips still faintly swollen from her mouth’s relentless suction, cock half-hard again just from the memory of her long, athletic frame arching beneath him.
But the house was silent.
Santiago’s bedroom door at the top of the stairs was closed, no light leaking beneath it. The kitchen table where his twin had been sitting earlier still held the half-empty protein shake glass, a faint ring of condensation marking where it had rested. Matteo kicked off his dress shoes, the polished leather scuffing softly against the hardwood, and padded upstairs in socked feet. His own room smelled like sex and latex and the faint, lingering trace of her musky sweetness on the sheets he hadn’t bothered to strip yet. He dropped onto the edge of the mattress, elbows on his knees, and stared at the floor between his bare feet.
The high from the night was already thinning, like fog burning off under the first weak rays of the sun. He ran a hand over his cropped hair, feeling the textured fade still slightly damp from their shared shower, and let out a slow breath that carried the weight of something he couldn’t name out loud.
It always came back to this.
Matteo had learned to fill every quiet space with noise. He was the twin who talked first, laughed loudest, and organized backyard games, charming the neighbors into extra slices of pan dulce. Santiago, born five minutes later, had always been the mirror opposite: steady, watchful, content to sit on the porch steps with a book while the world spun around him. Their parents used to joke that God had split one soul between them. Matteo got the fire, Santiago got the calm. But as they grew, Matteo started to feel the crack in that joke. The fire kept him warm, sure. It got him the rowing scholarship, the easy smiles from girls, and the reputation that followed him like a shadow across the Stanford campus. But the fire burned through the fuel, and lately the tank was always empty by morning.
He stood, peeling off the navy button-down he’d worn to dinner, the fabric still carrying the ghost of Aubrey’s fingers tugging at the buttons. His reflection in the full-length mirror on the closet door caught him off guard: six-foot-six of golden-brown skin, chiseled from erg sessions that started at 5 a.m. and weight lifts that left his shoulders burning. The kind of body that turned heads in every gym, every party, every grocery aisle. He looked like the guy who had it all figured out. The ladies’ man. The freshman who already had upperclassmen texting him at midnight. Intellectually bright, at the top of his pre-law cohort, quick with arguments in the debate club, and sharper than most of the juniors in his business ethics seminar. Kind, too; he’d stayed up until 3 a.m. last week helping his roommate study for a chem midterm even though he had practice at dawn. Sweet in the way he remembered birthdays and brought coffee to the boathouse crew without being asked.
But none of that touched the hollow spot behind his sternum.
Matteo crossed to the window, pushing the blinds open just enough to let the emerging gray light spill across the rumpled bed. He could still see the faint indent where Aubrey’s head had rested, the way her long, powerful legs had splayed open afterward, skin flushed and glistening. The memory sent a fresh pulse of heat through him, her primal groans, the way her smooth, hairless mound had glistened under his tongue, the vise-grip of her inner muscles milking him dry inside that overstretched condom. God, she’d been incredible. Confident, unapologetic, matching his hunger without hesitation. For those hours, the void had vanished. He’d felt wanted. Seen. Needed, even if only in the rawest, most physical way.
But now, in the quiet, it rushed back in like cold water.
He thought of the cycle he’d fallen into since high school. The first time had been junior year, after a big regatta win. A girl from the rival crew team had pulled him into the boathouse locker room, laughing, hands eager. He’d left that night grinning, chest puffed, telling himself this was what winning felt like. But the next morning, the same empty room, the same silence, he’d felt it: the ache. Like he’d poured everything out and nothing had poured back in. So he chased the next one. And the next. Freshman orientation at Stanford had been a blur of parties and willing bodies, sorority girls who liked the way he looked in a tank top, fellow athletes who understood the grind, even a quiet librarian type who’d blushed when he’d asked her to coffee and then ridden him like she was trying to erase her own loneliness. Each time the high was sharper, the release was more intense. Each time the crash came faster.
He sank onto the bed again, back against the headboard, one long leg stretched out, the other bent. His hand absently traced the faint red lines Aubrey’s nails had left on his thigh during that last explosive orgasm. The touch was almost soothing, but it only sharpened the contrast.
Santiago never seemed to need any of it.
That was the part that gnawed at him most. Last month, after a brutal Sunday practice, Matteo had come home wired and restless, scrolling through his phone for someone to text. He’d found Santiago in the living room, curled up on the couch with a dog-eared copy of some philosophy text, a single lamp on, the rest of the house dark. No music. No screens. Just… sitting. Content. When Matteo had dropped onto the opposite cushion and asked, half-joking, “Don’t you ever get bored, man?” Santiago had looked up with that quiet half-smile they shared, the one that made their faces identical but their eyes completely different.
“Bored? Nah. I like the quiet. Let me hear myself think.” Santiago had closed the book, marking his place with a finger. “You’re always running from it, bro. What are you chasing?”
Matteo had laughed it off then, cracking a joke about chasing tail and scholarships. But the question had lodged in his chest like a splinter. Santiago could sit in the quiet because he didn’t need the constant validation of a new conquest to feel solid. He had the same golden-brown skin, the same chiseled frame from the same genetics and the same rowing workouts, but somehow his twin had figured out how to be whole without filling every empty hour with someone else’s moans or laughter or hands on his body. Matteo envied it with a fierceness that surprised him. He wanted that peace. He wanted to wake up alone and not feel the immediate, clawing need to text someone, to plan the next hookup, to prove he was wanted.
Yet here he was, twenty minutes after dropping Aubrey at her dorm with a friends-with-benefits agreement that felt safe and clean and exactly what he’d told her he wanted, and the yearning was already gnawing again. Not for another body, though God knew the female student body at Stanford offered endless, diverse temptations that made his pulse kick just thinking about it. The tall, elegant dancers from the arts quad; the fierce, compact gymnasts who could match his stamina; the brilliant, sharp-tongued debate girls who challenged him in class and then challenged him in bed. He craved all of it, the variety, the thrill, the way each new encounter let him reinvent himself for a night.
But deeper, buried under the extrovert grin and the ladies’ man reputation, was the part that scared him: the quiet craving for the very thing he’d sworn he wasn’t ready for. A connection that didn’t end when the condom came off. Someone who saw past the six-foot-six frame and the easy charm to the guy who sometimes lay awake, wondering if he was enough without the performance. Someone whose quiet mornings felt like home instead of a vacuum. Someone he could sit with in the dark, no words needed, and still feel full.
Matteo exhaled sharply, scrubbing a hand down his face. The first true rays of sunlight were creeping through the blinds now, painting stripes across his bare chest. He could hear Santiago stirring in the next room, soft footsteps, the low hum of a kettle starting. His twin would come downstairs soon, make coffee without comment, maybe offer a knowing look, but never push. That was the thing about Santiago: he never needed to chase the void because he’d never let it form in the first place.
Matteo stood, muscles still loose and warm from the night, and headed for the shower. The water would be hot, the steam thick enough to blur the mirror again. He’d wash away the last traces of Aubrey’s scent, the dried evidence of their shared pleasure, and step out renewed. Ready to chase the next high when the schedule allows. Because that was the deal they’d made friends with benefits, no strings, no expectations.
But as the spray hit his shoulders and he closed his eyes, letting the water sluice down the hard planes of his body, Matteo felt the familiar pang settle back into place behind his ribs. Temporary relief. Temporary fill. The void, patient as ever, waited for the high to fade.
It always did.
Back in her dorm room, Aubrey slipped into bed with a deep, satisfied sigh. By labeling it a friends-with-benefits relationship, she had perfectly protected her fortress. No expectations of being someone’s girlfriend, no standard feminine pressures, just an athlete and student who occasionally let herself enjoy a man who wasn’t intimidated by her height, her strength, or her drive. She closed her eyes, the memory of Matteo’s touch still warm on her skin, and drifted into a deep, untroubled sleep.
The off-campus rental house was wrapped in the deep hush of 2:00 a.m. on a Saturday, the kind of quiet that amplified every small sound: the faint tick of the wall clock in the kitchen, the distant hum of a car passing on the street outside, the soft creak of the worn leather sofa as Sadie shifted slightly. Her grueling midterms were finally over, two weeks of relentless cramming, caffeine-fueled all-nighters, and anxiety that had knotted her stomach into a constant ache. The chaotic sea of textbooks, flashcards, and highlighters that had dominated the coffee table for days had been cleared away, stacked neatly on the bookshelf by Santiago earlier that evening with his usual quiet efficiency. Now, the living room was dimly lit by a single reading lamp on the side table, its warm yellow glow casting long shadows across the hardwood floors and turning the space into an intimate cocoon.
Sadie was curled up sideways on the bed, her petite frame nestled against Santiago's massive one. Her legs were draped casually over his powerful thighs, bare feet tucked under a throw blanket, while her head rested against his broad, solid chest. Beneath the soft cotton of his T-shirt, she could feel the rhythmic, steady thumping of his heart, a deep, reassuring bass line that had lulled her through countless study sessions. His arm was wrapped around her shoulders, large hand absently stroking her raven waves, fingers threading through the silky strands with gentle repetition. The air smelled faintly of the chamomile tea they'd shared earlier, calm and herbal, mingled with the clean, cedar-salt scent of his skin from his post-practice shower. It was peaceful. Safe. But beneath the surface, Sadie's mind was a storm.
She suddenly sat up.
Not fully away, she didn't pull her legs from his lap, but she created just enough physical space to straighten her spine, the motion pulling her head from his chest. Her heart hammered against her ribs, a frantic tattoo that made her breath catch. She reached up and pushed her wire-rimmed glasses up the bridge of her nose with one finger, a habitual "tell," her pre-med armor snapping into place as she braced for impact. The lenses caught the lamplight, flashing briefly, hiding the vulnerability in her electric-blue eyes for a split second.
Santiago's hand paused mid-stroke, his dark brown eyes lifting to meet hers. Concern flickered there, soft, questioning, but he didn't speak. He simply waited, as he always did.
Sadie looked down at her hands, twisting them in her lap. Her nails were bitten short from midterm stress, cuticles ragged. She took a shaky breath, the air shaking from her lungs.
"I haven't been fully honest with you, Santiago," she whispered. Words hung in the quiet room, fragile and raw.
Santiago's brow furrowed slightly, but he remained still, his large frame a steady anchor beside her. "What do you mean?"
Her heart hammered harder, tachycardia, her brain supplied automatically, but she pushed the clinical detachment aside. This wasn't a diagnosis. This was a confession.
"The last month..." She swallowed, throat tight. "After you told me about... getting laid. I couldn't handle the jealousy. So I stopped sharing. I thought if I omitted the details, I could keep exploring without hurting you or losing you."
She risked a glance at him. His expression was unreadable, eyes dark, jaw set, but he nodded once, encouraging her to continue.
"I sought out others," she said, voice cracking on the admission. "To test if the spark was real with you, or if I could find it elsewhere. Trevor, Julian, Chloe... across the hall. Safe, expectation-free nights. No pressure."
Santiago's hands had stilled completely, but he didn't pull away. Sadie's voice cracked fully now, tears welling up despite her best efforts.
"I did it because I was terrified," she confessed, electric-blue eyes finally meeting his dark brown ones. They shimmered with unshed tears, vulnerability laid bare. "Terrified of becoming like the women in my family, shrinking my life, my ambitions, to fit a man's ego. Giving up med school dreams for marriage and kids. I thought scattering my attention, sowing oats, rebelling, was the only way to protect my independence. To prove I owned myself."
She reached out, small hand covering his larger one, fingers trembling.
"But the experiment failed," she whispered, voice thick with emotion. "None of them has the spark. It's only you. It's always been you, Santiago. Your kindness, your patience, the way you see my ambition, and all. I was too scared to admit it."
Sadie braced herself then for the anger she deserved, the wounded pride flashing in his eyes, the way he might stand up, use his imposing 6'6" frame to create distance, and quietly ask her to leave. Her chest ached with anticipation, lungs tight, as though the air had thinned.
But Santiago didn't move away.
Instead, his large, veiny hands reached out gently, deliberately, and cupped her porcelain face. His thumbs brushed softly across her cheekbones, wiping away the tears that had escaped. His touch was warm, callused from oars and weights, but infinitely tender, the same hands that had always handled her like something precious.
"I know, Sadie," he rumbled quietly. His voice was a deep, soothing vibration that resonated through her body, wrapping around her like a blanket.
She blinked, stunned. "What?"
He held her gaze, no malice in his expression, only profound understanding. "I know. The scents of colognes, perfumes and oil paint in your hair some nights. The indie club stamp on your wrist that you tried to scrub off. The schedule inconsistencies. I saw it all."
Sadie's breath hitched, fresh tears spilling. "Why didn't you say anything?"
His thumbs continued their soft strokes, anchoring her. "Because I promised you I'd wait until you were ready. And I didn't want to corner you before you figured it out for yourself. I trusted you'd come back to me."
The sheer, overwhelming grace of his patience, the way he had observed, known, and still chosen to wait, broke the last remnants of her Catholic guilt and defensive armor. A choked sob escaped her throat, raw and unfiltered. She leaned heavily into his massive palms, tears soaking his skin, body trembling as the weight of her omissions finally lifted.
Sadie wiped her eyes with the back of her hand, her pre-med pragmatism resurfacing, but this time fueled by fierce devotion rather than fear. She straightened slightly in his hold, voice gaining strength even as it wavered.
"If we do this," she said, "the casual 'friends with benefits' is dead. I want to be committed to you. But you must understand my timeline, Santiago. I'm not just here for four years. Med school. Pediatric residency. That's seven, maybe eight years before I have a normal sleep schedule. I'll miss dates. I'll be exhausted, buried in charts and rotations. I need to know if you're built for the long run because I can't be with someone who'll resent my ambition eventually."
Santiago's signature warm smile slowly, genuinely spread across his face, lighting his brown eyes with profound, boundless reverence. He looked at her not just with desire, but with the kind of love that saw every flaw and chose her anyway. His hands slid from her face to her waist, pulling her fully into his lap, wrapping his long, powerful arms around her petite frame, anchoring her completely against his chest.
"While you're saving kids," he said, voice thick with affection, "I'm going to be a business finance major focusing on green tech and ethical startups. A career with its own grueling hours, travel, and deals that keep me up all night. We can build our empires side by side, Sadie. Support each other through the chaos.I’ll gladly sow all of your wild oats and your non-wild oats."
He paused, smile deepening. "Besides, I've already told my parents about you. They're heavily invested."
Sadie blinked, stunned, pulling back slightly in his arms. "You talk to your parents about me?"
Santiago chuckled, a deep, rumbling sound that vibrated against her chest, sending a shiver through her. "Yeah. My mom loves that you're going into pediatrics, says it's a calling. And my dad... Well, he laughed and said any girl willing to take on a Calder is an absolute saint, so he's entirely on your side."
The words landed softly at first.
Then her analytical mind caught on the unfamiliar surname, sharp and sudden.
Sadie blinked once, then again. Her cheek stayed against him, her brows drawing together in the focused look she always had when something didn’t make sense.
She raised her head slowly, carefully, and almost reluctantly. One slim finger pushed her glasses up with the familiar nudge that always made Santiago's heart ache tenderly.
"Wait," she said. Her voice was soft, still husky from earlier cries and whispers, but the tone underneath was pure curiosity laced with confusion. "Take on a Calder? Tiago... I thought your last name was Morales. Why would your dad call you a Calder?"
The room went very still.
Santiago froze. A sharp, involuntary clench beneath her palm; his breath caught, almost painfully. He met her gaze—the vivid blue of her eyes anchoring him, searching for truth with aching intensity.
He could lie. A joke. An old family nickname. Easy deflection.
But tonight was about walls coming down. About truth, even the parts that felt too big to hold.
He exhaled slowly, the sound heavy in the quiet. His large hands slid up her bare arms, goosebumps rising under his fingertips, until they settled on her shoulders, grounding them both.
"Morales is my mother's maiden name," he said quietly, each word measured. "Matteo and I use it at Stanford to stay under the radar. My dad’s name is Daniel Calder."
He watched her face carefully, with respect and a hint of nervousness, as if waiting for something powerful to happen.
The name meant nothing. Sadie’s world was anatomy and survival, not business. But seeing the tension locking his jaw, the uncertainty in his eyes, the truth struck her: she mattered, and he was scared to lose her.
He offered a small, crooked smile, self-deprecating, almost shy.
"He runs one of the largest investment funds in the country. If we used his name, people wouldn't see Matteo and me. They'd just see his bank account and think we bought our way through life."
Everything made sense.
The sprawling off-campus house that never felt like a student rental. The way he covered dinner tabs without glancing at totals. The absence of the frantic part-time-job energy she saw in other undergrads.
Her eyes widened fractionally. She sat up a little straighter, sheets pooling around her waist, exposing the soft curve of her breasts and the delicate line of her collarbone still flushed from earlier.
The truth struck her hard, making her suddenly aware of the gap between their lives, full of power and comfort; hers, built from cheap meals and long nights studying. Her heart raced with a mix of awe, fear, and the hope she wouldn’t lose him to that difference. The first curl of anxiety could take root, before she could start wondering what a girl like her looked like next to that kind of legacy, Santiago moved.
His large, rough hands from years of rowing cupped her face gently. His thumbs brushed her cheekbones and lifted her chin so she had to look at him.
"But that's his empire, Sadie," he said, voice dropping to that deep, unshakable rumble that always steadied her. "Not mine. I am building my own legacy. I'm going to earn my own way in green tech. I just happen to be incredibly blessed to come from a family that actually supports me unconditionally."
His dark brown eyes held hers without flinching. No arrogance. No entitlement. Just the same quiet certainty she'd seen when he carried her books across campus in the rain, when he stayed up with her until dawn, quizzing her on pathways even though he had practice at six.
She looked into his eyes, searching for any sign of pride or distance that money sometimes brings. She found nothing like that.
Only the gentle giant who'd let her sob into his shirt over a failed practice exam, who'd kissed her tears away and then made her laugh until her sides ached.
A sob caught in her throat, love, gratitude, disbelief welling so tightly she could hardly breathe.
She leaned forward again, resting her forehead against the warm, solid plane of his chest. Listened to the strong, even beat beneath her ear. Her small hand slid up, fingers tracing the thick cord of muscle at the side of his neck, feeling the faint throb of his pulse there.
She lifted her face slowly. Her eyes were clear and open, full of something deep and honest.
"You can tell Mr. Calder that his son is officially off the market." Her lips curved in the smallest, softest smile. "Because I'm not doing this residency, or this life, without you."
She rose just enough to brush her mouth along the sharp line of his jaw once, feather-light, then again, lingering. The faint scrape of stubble against her lips sent a shiver through her.
"I love you, Tiago."
Hearing her nickname for him, spoken so gently, shattered the last wall around his heart.
He slid one hand to the back of her neck, his fingers weaving into her hair and holding her gently. He lifted her face and kissed her.
Not hungry. Not urgent.
Agonizingly slow.
Reverent.
His lips brush. He kissed her softly at first, then again, tasting the faint salt of her skin. He gently caught her bottom lip, then let it go with a quiet breath. His tongue traced her lips until she parted them for him with a small, shaky sigh. He poured himself into the kiss, every ounce of his hopelessly romantic heart locked behind easy smiles. Deep, languid strokes. The slow glide of his tongue against hers. The way he angled his head to fit them together perfectly, as though he'd memorized the shape of her mouth weeks ago.
He wrapped his other arm around her waist, pulling her on to his lap, until their bodies pressed together. He caught her soft sound and answered with a low, quiet noise from deep in his chest.
When they finally parted just enough to breathe, foreheads resting together, noses brushing, he whispered against her swollen lips. A long thick bulge grew from his lap, pressing against her soft behind.
"I love you too, Sadie."
His thumb stroked the sensitive skin behind her ear. "More than I know how to say yet."
She smiled slightly, radiant, and kissed the corner of his mouth. Then his cheek. Then settled back against his chest, listening once more to the steady thunder of his heart as it matched the pulse she felt radiating from his lap.
This time, his heart beat for her.
And she knew, without a doubt, that it always would.
—-
The void had settled over Matteo Morales like a second skin, thick, suffocating, impossible to shrug off. Two weeks. Fourteen endless days since Barbie had begun her flawless psychological chess game, dangling herself just out of reach with those sly, knowing smiles and the way she’d brush past him in the library stacks, leaving only the faint trace of her vanilla-amber perfume and the echo of her laughter. Meanwhile, Judy, his fiery, take-charge rowing captain, had vanished into a vortex of midterm hell and team leadership, her texts reduced to curt emojis and promises of “later, big guy.” No late-night workouts that turned into sweat-slicked collisions against the boathouse wall. No breathless, laughing dominance matches where she pinned his wrists and demanded he earn every thrust.
Matteo paced the wide, sunlit quad outside the Business School, his 6’6” frame cutting through clusters of students like a blade. Golden-brown skin gleamed under the late-afternoon light, the tight dark long sleeve shirt he wore clinging to every carved ridge of his torso defined pecs that strained the fabric, abs etched like stone beneath, and the sharp V of his hips arrowing down to where his heavy cock already throbbed with restless frustration. Two weeks of nothing but his own hand and cold showers had left him feral. The territorial fire Barbie had lit in his blood still burned low and hot, refusing to die. Every time he closed his eyes, he saw her arched back, and heard Judy’s husky laugh as she rode him, as she owned him. His balls ached with it. His mind wouldn’t shut the fuck up.
And the whispers… God, the whispers had only made it worse.
He’d caught them in the locker room, in the dining hall, even in the back row of his Business Ethics lecture hall. “Morales monster.” “That rower with the unstoppable stamina.” “I heard he fucked three girls in one night and still went for a 5 a.m. erg session.” Sorority houses had turned his name into legend, rumors of his veiny, forearm-thick cock, the sheer volume of his releases, the way he could go for hours without softening, the dominant growl that made girls tremble and beg. Matteo had always enjoyed his reputation, but now it felt like a taunt. The ladies’ man who could have anyone, yet the only two he craved had decided to starve him.
He shoved his hands into his pockets, jaw tight, beautiful brown eyes narrowed beneath the textured crop of his dark hair. The arrogant scowl he wore like armor deepened as he pushed through the heavy double doors of the lecture hall, the last of the stadium seating emptying behind him. Restless energy coiled in his long, powerful legs; his broad shoulders rolled with each stride. He needed an outlet. Needed to fuck the frustration out of his system before he snapped.
That was when they flanked him.
Sienna and Harper moved as they’d rehearsed it, two stunning sorority sisters in perfect sync, both blonde but in complementary shades, both dressed in tiny tennis skirts and cropped tops that left miles of tanned, toned skin on display. Sienna’s platinum waves bounced as she stepped directly into his path, her manicured fingers already lifting to trail boldly down the center of his chest, pressing through the thin Henley to feel the heat of his skin. Harper, with her honey-gold curls and glossy pink lips, circled to his other side, close enough that her signature floral-citrus perfume wrapped around him like smoke.
“Matteo Morales,” Sienna purred, voice low and velvet-rough, her blue eyes sparkling with zero shame. “We’ve been watching you all semester. Every lecture. Every workout on the quad. And we’ve heard.”
Harper leaned in, her breath warm against his ear, full breasts brushing his arm. “The Morales monster. That legendary cock. The stamina that leaves girls shaking for days.” Her hand slid down his bicep, tracing the thick veins that popped even when he wasn’t flexing. “We want to know if the legend’s real. No games. No strings. Just you. Us. In our room. Right now.”
Sienna’s fingers dipped lower, grazing the waistband of his jeans, feeling the growing bulge there. “We’re roommates. We share everything. And we want to share you.” Her smile was pure sin. “Say yes, and we’ll make sure every rumor becomes an understatement.”
Matteo’s asymmetrical shark smile flashed slowly, devastating, the one that had dropped panties across campus for two years. His brown eyes darkened with predatory hunger, the feral energy surging. These two weren’t Judy’s challenging fire or Barbie’s mindfuck unpredictability, but right now? They were exactly the distraction his bruised ego and aching cock demanded. “Lead the way, ladies,” he rumbled, voice deep and commanding, already imagining the ways he’d wreck them.
The sorority room was a sun-drenched, pastel paradise with white walls, fluffy rugs, and a king-sized bed dominating the bedroom like an altar. The moment the door clicked shut, the dynamic shifted into pure, unadulterated worship. No power struggle. No psychological chess. Just two gorgeous, uninhibited women putting on a show crafted entirely for him.
Matteo dropped onto the bed, back against the padded headboard, long legs spread wide. He didn’t undress them; he commanded. “Strip. Slowly. I want to watch.” His voice was velvet steel, and they obeyed instantly, peeling off tops and skirts with performative grace, kissing each other deeply as they went, tongues sliding, hands roaming. Soft, perfect breasts pressed together; nipples hardened into tight peaks. Their skin glowed, Sienna’s pale cream, Harper’s sun-kissed gold contrasting sharply against his own golden-brown expanse when they finally crawled to him.
He pulled them in with those massive, calloused rower’s hands, strong, long arms flexing so the veins stood out like ropes. The sensory overload hit him immediately: the silky slide of four soft thighs straddling his lap, the wet heat of two mouths on his neck, the intoxicating mix of their perfumes and the growing musk of arousal. His shirt was yanked off, revealing the chiseled perfection beneath pecs like marble, abs rippling with every breath, that light trail of dark hair arrowing down to the massive bulge straining his jeans.
They freed him together, gasping in unison when his thick, heavy cock sprang free nine inches of veined, golden-brown perfection, already leaking at the tip, girth so substantial that both their manicured hands could barely circle it side by side.
“Oh my God,” Harper breathed, eyes wide with genuine awe. “It’s even bigger than they said.”
Sienna licked her lips. “Let’s see if we can handle the legend.”
They worked in flawless tandem, mouths and tongues everywhere. Harper took the head first, stretching her glossy lips wide around the fat crown, sucking greedily while Sienna’s tongue painted wet circles around the thick base and heavy balls, sucking one into her mouth with a wet pop. Their hands stroked in unison along the endless length up, down, twisting while they kissed around his shaft, tongues flicking against each other and against his pulsing vein. Matteo’s head fell back, a low groan rumbling from his chest, one hand fisting Harper’s honey curls, the other tangling in Sienna’s platinum waves. He dictated the rhythm, guiding them deeper, faster, until Harper’s throat convulsed around him.
“Fuck I’m gonna come,” he growled.
The first eruption was volcanic. Thick ropes of hot, white semen flooded Harper’s mouth in such volume that she gagged, eyes watering beautifully, creamy excess spilling from the corners of her lips and cascading down his shaft in heavy rivulets. Sienna was there instantly, tongue lapping greedily at the overflow, suctioning every drop from his balls and base like she was starving. Harper pulled off with a gasp, strings of cum connecting her lips to his cock, and Sienna rose to kiss her deep, filthy, tongues swirling as they passed his salty, thick load back and forth in a messy, glistening exchange right in front of his eyes.
The sight alone made Matteo’s cock surge harder, blood pounding. “Again,” he ordered, voice rough. They switched. Sienna swallowed him this time, managing to contain the second massive load while Harper worshipped his balls, sucking and licking until he erupted again. Sienna pulled Harper up into another cum-swapping kiss, letting the thick white nectar dribble between their tongues, down their chins, onto their heaving breasts. Matteo watched every second, chest rising and falling, the power thrumming through him like a drug.
They experimented through position after position, bodies slick with sweat and cum. He took Sienna from behind while Harper slid underneath in a perfect 69, her mouth devouring Sienna’s swollen clit and occasionally licking the base of his pistoning cock. Each brutal thrust drove Sienna forward into Harper’s tongue; the wet sounds slapping skin, slurping mouths, desperate moans filled the room. When he came, it was a torrent inside Sienna, so much that it immediately leaked out around his thickness. He pulled free, and Harper dove in, tongue-fucking her roommate’s dripping pussy, sucking every drop of his cum out while fingering Sienna through another shattering orgasm.
They traded. Harper is on all fours now, Sienna is beneath, licking her clit as Matteo pounds deep, his powerful hips snapping, long legs braced, veiny arms gripping Harper’s waist hard enough to leave fingerprints. Another enormous load flooded Harper, and Sienna cleaned her just as eagerly, kissing her afterward so they could share the taste again.
Matteo’s legendary rowing endurance never faltered. He fucked them through three more rounds, riding them, flipping them, using their bodies like the perfect instruments they were until both girls were trembling, voices hoarse from screaming his name, thighs quivering, pussies swollen and leaking his cum in thick white trails down their legs. Sienna and Harper collapsed in a tangled, breathless heap on the ruined sheets, eyes glassy, lips parted, completely dismantled and thoroughly, blissfully satisfied.
Hours later, the Palo Alto evening had cooled. Matteo stood, muscles still humming with power, and pulled his shirt back over his chiseled torso. The girls dozed where they’d fallen, Sienna’s head on Harper’s stomach, both utterly wrecked, soft smiles on their faces. It was, objectively, his hottest campus conquest yet. Two stunning, performative worshippers who had received exactly what the legend promised.
He stepped outside into the crisp air, the arrogant smirk still lingering on his full lips for a moment until it faded.
His body was sated, balls finally empty, ego massively stroked. But his mind… his mind was already spinning, calculating, restless again. The threesome had been incredible, visually stunning, physically perfect, every sensory detail a feast. Yet it lacked the violent, teeth-clashing challenge he got from Judy’s dominant fire. It lacked the mind-bending, unpredictable psychological spark that Barbie ignited with a single glance. No feral territorial rush. No addictive chaos.
Matteo shoved his hands into his pockets, long, powerful legs carrying him down the sidewalk as the streetlights flickered on. A frustrated sigh escaped him, the sound low and raw in the quiet night.
He was officially addicted. And no amount of worship, no matter how beautiful or willing, was going to fill the void that was carved into him.
Do you like this story? If you do, you may be interested to know that the
author also has one other story on the site that are available
to the members of the EroticStories.com FanClub!
Click here to read more about the FanClub.
Request from webmaster Art:
Don't forget to vote for this story in the yellow voting box below!
Authors really appreciate the votes and it only takes a few seconds!
ESmail: Click here to send a private message to Storey Lover (with ESmail, the site's internal message system)
| This is part 6 of a total of 6 parts. | ||
| previous part | show all parts | |
|
Authors appreciate feedback! Please vote, and write to the authors to tell them what you liked or didn't like about the story!
|
|
Profile for Storey Lover, incl. 2 stories Add this author to your favorite author list Add this story to your favorite story list Send this story to me through email | |
|
Send feedback to this author:
Your name:
    (You are not logged in, so you can't send private messages) |
|
|
Click here for Sex dating! Have sex tonight! |
The best LIVE cams: Live webcam girls! Free chat! |
|
Erotic shop: so many toys to choose from! | |